Code Review and Improvements

November 16, 2023
You said:
role: a senior developer proficient in Python task: Your task is to review the code presented to you. This code will be run in a production environment so you should apply full code standards in your review. Present your feedback as a list and give the user a set of task to complete in order to bring the code up to standard. If you think the code is already up to standard, you can say that the code is good. You should be stern but fair in your review. Some rules that apply: code should be documented (in numpy style). code should be DRY. code should be readable. code should be efficient. finally, after completing your review. Give a verdict: either accept or reject the code. question: Please review the following code: """ import turtle win = turtle.Screen() win.title("Pong by Your Name") win.bgcolor("black") win.setup(width=1000, height=500) left_paddle = turtle.Turtle() left_paddle.speed(0) left_paddle.shape("square") left_paddle.color("white") left_paddle.shapesize(stretch_wid=6, stretch_len=1) left_paddle.penup() left_paddle.goto(-450, 0) right_paddle = turtle.Turtle() right_paddle.speed(0) right_paddle.shape("square") right_paddle.color("white") right_paddle.shapesize(stretch_wid=6, stretch_len=1) right_paddle.penup() right_paddle.goto(450, 0) ball = turtle.Turtle() ball.speed(40) ball.shape("square") ball.color("white") ball.penup() ball.goto(0, 0) ball.dx = 6 ball.dy = -2 score_left = 0 score_right = 0 score_display = turtle.Turtle() score_display.speed(0) score_display.color("white") score_display.penup() score_display.hideturtle() score_display.goto(0, 210) score_display.write("Left: 0 Right: 0", align="center", font=("Courier", 24, "normal")) def left_paddle_up(): y = left_paddle.ycor() if y < 250: left_paddle.sety(y + 20) def left_paddle_down(): y = left_paddle.ycor() if y > -240: left_paddle.sety(y - 20) def right_paddle_up(): y = right_paddle.ycor() if y < 250: right_paddle.sety(y + 20) def right_paddle_down(): y = right_paddle.ycor() if y > -240: right_paddle.sety(y - 20) win.listen() win.onkeypress(left_paddle_up, "w") win.onkeypress(left_paddle_down, "s") win.onkeypress(right_paddle_up, "Up") win.onkeypress(right_paddle_down, "Down") while score_left < 10 and score_right < 10: win.update() ball.setx(ball.xcor() + ball.dx) ball.sety(ball.ycor() + ball.dy) if ball.ycor() > 240: ball.sety(240) ball.dy *= -1 if ball.ycor() < -240: ball.sety(-240) ball.dy *= -1 if ball.xcor() > 490: ball.goto(0, 0) ball.dx *= -1 score_left += 1 score_display.clear() score_display.write("Left: {} Right: {}".format(score_left, score_right), align="center", font=("Courier", 24, "normal")) if ball.xcor() < -490: ball.goto(0, 0) ball.dx *= -1 score_right += 1 score_display.clear() score_display.write("Left: {} Right: {}".format(score_left, score_right), align="center", font=("Courier", 24, "normal")) if (ball.xcor() > 430 and ball.xcor() < 440) and (ball.ycor() < right_paddle.ycor() + 50 and ball.ycor() > right_paddle.ycor() - 50): ball.setx(430) ball.dx *= -1 if (ball.xcor() < -430 and ball.xcor() > -440) and (ball.ycor() < left_paddle.ycor() + 50 and ball.ycor() > left_paddle.ycor() - 50): ball.setx(-430) ball.dx *= -1 score_display.goto(0, 0) score_display.write("Game Over", align="center", font=("Courier", 32, "normal")) turtle.done() """
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT

Here is a review of the provided code:

  1. Code Documentation:

    • There is no documentation in the code to explain its purpose, the functions, or any important variables. It's important to provide clear and concise documentation for better code maintainability.

  2. Code DRYness (Don't Repeat Yourself):

    • There is a significant amount of repeated code for creating the left and right paddles. This could be refactored into a function to reduce duplication.

  3. Code Readability:

    • Variable names are generally clear and descriptive, which is good for readability.
    • The code structure is straightforward and easy to follow.
    • Consider adding comments to explain the purpose of specific sections of the code, such as the game loop or collision detection.

  4. Code Efficiency:

    • The code uses the turtle library for a basic pong game, so efficiency might not be a primary concern here. However, there are some optimizations that can be made:
      • Instead of repeatedly clearing and rewriting the score display when the score changes, you can use the clear() method once to clear the screen and then write the updated score. This will reduce unnecessary screen updates.
      • In the game loop, you can use a timer or an event-driven approach to control the game updates, rather than using a continuous while loop. This will make the code more efficient and responsive.

Tasks to Bring the Code up to Standard:

  1. Add comments and documentation to explain the purpose of the code, functions, and important variables. Use numpy-style docstrings for functions.

  2. Refactor the code to eliminate duplication when creating the left and right paddles by creating a function for paddle creation.

  3. Optimize the score display by clearing the screen once and then writing the updated score instead of clearing and rewriting it each time.

  4. Consider using an event-driven approach or a timer to control the game loop instead of a continuous while loop.

  5. Add comments to explain the logic of the collision detection and ball movement.

Verdict: The code is functional and creates a basic Pong game. However, it lacks proper documentation, has some duplication, and could benefit from minor optimizations for efficiency. Therefore, I would suggest making the recommended changes and improvements before considering it ready for production.

Continue this conversation
|Terms of use|Privacy policy|